Skip to Content Skip to Navigation
Member Login

Member login

No account? JOIN US
Press releases

Carers UK presses DWP to act on High Court ruling to exempt carers from benefit cap

22 January 2016

As the Government prepares to respond to a High Court ruling that the benefit cap unfairly discriminates against carers, Carers UK is calling for all carers to be exempt from the cap.

The call comes almost two months after the ruling was passed down and as the House of Lords is about to debate an amendment to the Welfare Reform and Work Bill1, which would exempt those on Carer’s Allowance from the cap.

Carers UK warns that delays or a failure to comply with the ruling will see people who care for a disabled, seriously-ill or older loved one unjustly facing greater financial hardship at the hands of the policy.  

1,400 carers are currently subject to the benefit cap.2 However, when the benefit cap is lowered in April 2016, more carers will be affected.3

Following a judicial review challenge, Justice Collins ruled that that the benefit cap unlawfully discriminates against the disabled claimants and their carers.4 The DWP did not contest the ruling but has not issued any new guidance to implement the ruling, leaving families in limbo.

Heléna Herklots, Chief Executive of Carers UK, supplied evidence to the High Court in support of the challenge. Ms Herklots said: 

“Two months have passed since the High Court ruled that the benefit cap unlawfully discriminates against disabled people and their carers. Whilst the Government considers its position on the ruling, carers continue to be unfairly penalised by this policy.

“The benefit cap places a further strain on the incomes of carers, many of whom are already facing serious financial hardship and struggling to make to ends meet as a result of their caring role. People who are providing full-time care to a loved one are finding it near-on impossible to cover the extra costs of the benefit cap.

“Carers contribute so much to society, indeed the value of their support is worth £132 billion to the UK economy every year. Subjecting those who provide unpaid care to the benefit cap is unfair and inconsistent with the Government’s own aim for the policy. The DWP must act now to enforce the High Court’s decision and amend legislation to ensure carers are no longer penalised by this unfair policy.”

Pressure on the DWP to exempt carers from the benefit cap is growing, with Rt Hon Frank Field MP, Chair of the Cross-Party Parliamentary Work and Pensions Committee, writing to Lord Freud, DWP Minister for Welfare Reform, calling for parents caring for adult children with a disability to be exempt from the policy.5

  • For more information on the benefit cap and how it affects carers, click here.
  • To read our benefit cap Q&A, click here.

Media contact

Case studies and spokespeople are available upon request.

Please contact Lisa Gilbert, Senior Media and Case Study Officer at Carers UK on This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it., 020 7378 4937 or 07534 630 667 (out of hours).

Notes to editors

1 Welfare Reform and Work Bill 2015-16:

2 DWP, Benefit cap: A review of the first year (2014):

3 The Government set out in its 2015 Budget (delivered on 8 July 2015) that the cap on the amount of benefits that can be claimed by one family will be reduced from £26,000 a year to £23,000 a year if you live in London and £20,000 a year if you live outside of London. The lowering of the benefit cap is expected to roll out from April 2016.

4 Hurley & Ors v Secretary of State for Work and Pensions [2015] EWHC 3382 (Admin): For more information about the High Court ruling on the benefit cap, see Carers UK’s Q&A:

Join us

Hands join us

Together we're a supportive community and a movement for change.



Your donations are an essential part of helping us make life better for carers.

How you can help

Carer and son

With your help we can reach more carers with timely support and advice.



We will keep campaigning until every carer gets proper recognition and support.

Back to top